Table 1

Levels of evidence and grades of recommendations

Level or gradeDescription
Level of evidence
IEvidence demonstrated by means of meta-analyses of well-designed controlled trials or large randomized trials with clear-cut results (low rate of false-positive and false-negative errors, high power)
IIEvidence demonstrated by means of small randomized trials with uncertain results (high rate of false-positive and false-negative errors, low power)
IIIEvidence demonstrated by means of nonrandomized concurrent cohort comparisons with contemporaneous controls
IVEvidence demonstrated by means of nonrandomized historical cohort comparisons
VEvidence demonstrated by means of case series without controls
Grade of recommendation
ASupported by Level I evidence or multiple Level II, III or IV trials presenting concordant observations
BSupported by Level II, III or IV trials presenting generally concordant observations
CSupported by Level II, III or IV trials presenting nonconcordant observations
DSupported by few trials or no empiric evidence
  • Adapted from Cook and colleagues13 with permission from the American College of Chest Physicians.