Table 4

Rates of agreement with statements in post-test survey: comparison of junior and senior residents

StatementNo. (%) of participants;* stage of trainingp value
Junior
n = 20
Senior
n = 16
The instructions at the beginning of the test were clear.13 (65.0)10 (62.5)0.80
The SCT examples (with answers) presented before the test were helpful.13 (65.0)9 (56.3)0.40
The test questions were clear.11 (55.0)5 (31.3)0.53
It was easy to adapt to this kind of test.7 (35.0)4 (25.0)0.50
The time allotted to complete the test was adequate.15 (75.0)6 (37.5)0.036
The questions reflected authentic clinical situations.15 (75.0)10 (62.5)0.34
The questions reflected situations that I have encountered or I am likely to encounter during my training/practice.14 (70.0)12 (75.0)0.56
This evaluation was useful for testing the ability to reason through cases in otolaryngology.10 (50.0)9 (56.3)0.80
  • SCT = script concordance testing.

  • * Participants who answered “agree” or “strongly agree.”